I'm not sure what is the most alarming aspect of CSIS testimony today that they will still use information that may have been obtained by torture in other countries "if lives are at stake" :
"Geoffrey O’Brian, a CSIS lawyer and advisor on operations and legislation, under questioning by the public safety committee, admitted there is no absolute ban on using intelligence that may have been obtained from countries with questionable human rights records on torture."
~ That CSIS continues to reward other countries for torture - when exactly are lives not "at stake"?
~ That they condone a practice which, in addition to being barbaric, is not even effective
~ That oversight of CSIS operations remains negligible
~ That recommendations from both the O'Connor and Iacobucci inquiries are being ignored
~ That we are now in open contravention of UN Convention Against Torture
~ That CSIS is comfortable being open about this, presumably based on the assumption there is sufficient public support
~ That about half of the 250+ public comments under a similar article at the G&M do indeed support the CSIS position, citing the necessity of preserving "republican" or "christian" or "North American" values, backed up with examples gleaned from the US TV drama 24 Hours.
Apparently in addition to condoning actions that prove we have lost the war on terrorism, we have also become a nation too stupid to safely operate a television.
Update : When I blogged this afternoon about this, I hadn't yet watched the actual proceedings.
Well now I have.
Apparently, according to O'Brian who is very keen on quoting the British House of Lords 2005 "torture decision", "the Executive is bound to make use of all information, both coerced statements and whatever fruits they bear, to safeguard the security of the state."
And if mistakes are made? Well there's always SIRC, the Security Intelligence Review Committee and source of glowing reports about CSIS, to complain to afterwords.
And further, we should be grateful and proud of that.
Also, just because a country has an "abysmal" human rights record, it doesn't necessarily follow that information we receive from them is extracted by torture. In fact, usually we have no idea how information is obtained, so - not our fault.
Do we continue to share info with Egypt and Syria? Yes, we share info with 247 agencies, with caveats of course. See SIRC above.
Does the Con chair of the committee plus the five Cons on it continually interrupt with points of order and run interference for the intelligence agencies phrased as questions? You betcha.
Also on this one : Skdadl and Dave
- ► 2015 (53)
- ► 2014 (129)
- ► 2013 (138)
- ► 2012 (58)
- ► 2011 (142)
- ► 2010 (279)
- CSIS just fine with tips "extracted" via torture
- Braidwood Inquiry : Blaming the victim
- George Galloway update : Would anyone else care to...
- F Words 2009!
- George Galloway Petitions : Let Him Speak vs Keep ...
- Canada throws up yet another roadblock to Abdelraz...
- George Galloway runs smack into the Canada-Israel ...
- RCMP : Getting away with murder
- Captioning the Braidwood Inquiry
- Braidwood Inquiry - The return of the Staples Defe...
- Canadian Club on Ice begins today
- Braidwood Inquiry resumes tomorrow; William Elliot...
- Canadians plan physical escort of Galloway into Ca...
- George Galloway vs the Canadian director of the Je...
- Matt Taibbi : The Big Takeover
- Jason Kenney spokesthingey Alykhan Velshi is an in...
- Canada bans Galloway
- RCMP runs out the clock on another inquiry
- Harper slashes RCMP watchdog funding
- The free market : it isn't free and it isn't a mar...
- Kady liveblogs the Manning Netwonking Conference
- Cramer vs Stewart
- Abdelrazik has his ticket!
- Cons to bring back anti-terrorism powers
- UN report on torture and rendition cites Canada
- "AirShow" MacKay's excellent NATO audition
- Viva Palestina! convoy has entered Gaza!
- Emma celebrates International Women's Day
- Viva Palestina! - media blackout
- The Canada-US Project : Deep integration redux
- Canada, Sudan, and the stench of hypocrisy
- Braidwood Inquiry : Can't get their stories straig...
- Braidwood Inquiry - A third officer is forced to r...
- The "Master Narrative" on Afghanistan
- ▼ March (34)
- ► 2008 (356)
- ► 2007 (317)
- ► 2006 (286)
- Canadian Progressive Voices
- 404 System Error
- A Creative Revolution
- Accidental Deliberations
- Another Voice
- April Reign
- Back of the Book
- Big City Lib
- Birth Pangs
- Blogging Change
- Bowen Island Journal
- Bread and Roses
- Canadian Cynic
- Challenging the Commonplace
- Council of Canadians
- Cracked Crystal Ball
- Crawl Across the Ocean
- CREEKSIDE - THE SPP POSTS
- DAMMIT JANET!
- Dawg's Blawg
- De Koboldorum Rebus
- Dymaxion World
- hairy fish nuts
- Harper Valley
- Just Another Willy Loman
- Laila Yuile
- Leftist Jab
- Let Freedom Rain
- Liberal Catnip
- Mirabile Dictu
- Montreal Simon
- Moved to Vancouver
- Murray Dobbin
- Northern Insights
- Of Gods & Other Monsters
- Open Parliament
- Orwell's Bastard
- Paying Attention
- Politics 'n Poetry
- Public Eye Online
- Pushed to the Left and Loving It
- Q at North of Center
- Red Tory
- Resettle THIS!
- Rose's Place
- Runesmith's Canadian Content
- Rusty Idols
- Steve & Sandra Toons
- Terrible Depths
- The Black Ewe
- The Dominion
- The Galloping Beaver
- The Gazetteer
- The Regina Mom
- The Sixth Estate
- The Tyee
- The Woodshed
- They Call Me "Mr. Sinister"
- Thinking Aboot
- Thwap's Schoolyard
- Trapped in a Whirlpool
- Unrepentant Old Hippie
- Youngfox Canada